Disc Replay Castleton

Fantastic experience: Great service great collection

Fantastic experience: The emo baddie was very helpful and knowledgeable about labubus

Fantastic experience: Mallory and staff are superlative in their customer service and patience!

Fantastic experience: Christina, Jose, and Mars were very helpful and informative throughout the whole selling process! :)

Fantastic experience: Lots ok cool products . Highly recommend

Positive experience: Staff was knowledgeable about games and parts. Very pleasant experience.

Fantastic experience: I really love that places like Disc Replay is still around so we can have a physical copy of the movies you loved growing up (and three to four DVDs for 10 dollars!). If you like watching a movie with a DVD player, this is a place to look first.

Fantastic experience: Jose was awsome! Great selection. Paid more for my trade ins than any other shop in the area.

Fantastic experience: Came in a few days ago Reid was an excellent help! Greeted me with a smile and was very helpful and answered all my questions! Definitely very nice and pleasant experience

Fantastic experience: Staff members were attentive and asking customers if they needed any help, store was clean and well kept. Had more items and apparel than other disc replay stores, has everything you need and more!

Fantastic experience: The team there is always fast,friendly and knowledgeable. The gentleman that helped was new but he was kind and patient with me. I will definitely do business there again.

Fantastic experience: Staff is always great!! I sold most of collection to this location. Very nice and fair with sale offers. Always best place to sell your blu-rays.

Fantastic experience: Love coming here. They have a wide variety of games and consoles to choose from as well as posters. Love the employees, Alexis was very friendly. Will definitely frequent

Fantastic experience: James was very helpful patient and kind. He helped me get bags of DVDs from my car.

Fantastic experience: The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable.They have so much patience and kindness for people facing challenges.

Fantastic experience: Was so happy to discover this place. They have pretty much anything associated with video games, from Atari to today. Bought a cool Vault-Tec poster there I've never seen before. Very helpful staff too.

Fantastic experience: I brought in some items to trade in and bought a couple of things in store. I had a couple questions and Kenny and the rest of the staff were very knowledgeable and helpful.

Positive experience: If your going into the store to buy it truly is a good place to shop they have alot of great deals every thing is priced to sell quick and rightfully so this location does alot of buy and sell making tons of profit I shopped nothing but the exchange for DVD bluray movies also most game consoles not all like the replay and have been a vip Cardholder since they opened store but I went in yesterday needing extra cash was told to get in line then waiting 30 to 45 minutes was told sorry we can't help you today we already got 2 big orders in and we hate to inform you we can't help well now after calling that store to make sure I could sell my items and turned away living 45min away am stuck with little gas but thanks to finding disc replay who had 7 orders ahead of me didn't turn me away and even though I had to wait that was fine I waited 3 hrs for them to go thru the orders before me and then mine walked out with enough to get me and my daughter home and get us some food they don't pay but 25 cent per DVD but like 2.50 on bluray they don't buy cds but they do buy pops figures accessories all games and all systems and I have to tell you they have some magic when it comes to fixing a disc I had a double cd album I got for Christmas almost 25 years ago that hasn't worked in 23 of those years I took to them thinking the album was trash paid 2.50 and omg the albums work again like brand new im in shock and awe that alone was worth going to this store I found a new store for everything but music and to the exchange you lost a vip card holding customer it's just not what it was a couple of years ago I guess because the people are different and they no longer care about their customers and it's sad disc replay for the win though

Fantastic experience: Was very nice even though the store was almost closing! Thank you!

Fantastic experience: Disc Replay is an awesome game store. I always enjoy going there and looking at what’s new. Stores are always clean and well organized. The employees are knowledgeable and helpful. Bridget at the Castleton store stands out. It is always pleasant working with her.

Fantastic experience: James is always willing to help and very knowledgeable of all gaming systems.

Fantastic experience: This place has it all. Really cool gaming store with very reasonable prices. the staff here is very nice and pleasant. I will return here.

Fantastic experience: I go here every couple months to see what games/movies I can find again from childhood. They have a great selection that I keep coming back for! Christina helped me today and I appreciate her service!

Fantastic experience: Alexis did great work and was very personable. Happy with my experience.

Fantastic experience: Alexis was very fun to talk to about lord of the rings!

Positive experience: This location sucks now. I cant find any movies or old games anymore. They're all at the east Washington location plus the customer service is LACKING. Used to be great...

Fantastic experience: My son and I came in to see if a game disc could be repaired. Alexis greated us with a smile and ask how she could help. We explained our issue a she helped us. We ended up purchasing another game disc. She was very helpful. I want to give her a 5 star review.

Negative experience: I bought a PS3 there, it wasn't the Phat Model that is backwards compatible with both PS1 and PS2 games. Which is my fault I should have looked before purchasing. My real complaint is that I bought a limited edition PS3 Final Fantasy X|X-2 HD Remaster and when I got home the game disk wasn't even in the box. They sold me an empty box lol. Check your games to make sure they gave them to you before you leave the register.

Fantastic experience: Very helpful and friendly staff.

Fantastic experience: Raven was incredibly friendly & helpful. She made my Disc Replay Experience a 10/10!!

Fantastic experience: Jose is great super helpful, knowledgeable and friendly!

Fantastic experience: I really appreciate that when selling them items. They took the time to explain the process, offered a very fair deal for my items and had a staggering selection of items at very reasonable prices for me to buy. If you’re anything from a gamer, movie buff or anime junkie. This is the place to get your fix. Don’t hesitate to stop in and check it out. Also shout out to James and really all the staff for their help!

Fantastic experience: Alexis was super friendly and fun to talk to about the Wii U and Zelda WindWaker HD!

Fantastic experience: Loved the variety of retro items and great finds! ☺️

Fantastic experience: Great service, Christina and Jose were very helpful!

Fantastic experience: Mal, Christina, and Mars are goated. Very helpful and goes above and beyond to make sure you leave happy with what you wanted.

Fantastic experience: Kenny was very pleasant to work with and knowledgeable. I will definitely return.

Fantastic experience: This is one of my favorite places! Alexis is always the best!!!! She greets me with a smile every time I’m in and is always there for me when I have a question. Everyone else there does a great job as well, but Alexis is my favorite!!!!

Fantastic experience: Jose needs a raise! Good dude, easy going, got me exactly what I needed.

Fantastic experience: The service is great! Prices are too!

Fantastic experience: James did a great job. I could tell he was new and he was absorbing being new

Fantastic experience: Experience was great, Jose helped me with a trade in and Christina helped me with buying a switch 2, very friendly, staff will be back soon

Fantastic experience: This is a wonderful store. Great selection of games and used equipment. Alexis gave us incredible service and took time to answer many questions. On another visit, Mars was a wonderful support as well. This is a great team and they clearly know games very well well (and love them!).

Positive experience: Service from the employees was good however i was not impressed with the amount that the paid me for my Xbox, wee and games. Seems to me it was about one third of their value.

Fantastic experience: I had a great experience with Alexis she was very knowledgeable, kind and got the sale done quickly!! She is overall a 5 Star Employee !!!

Fantastic experience: Pretty Good place, good selection and nice staff Christian was helpful in selling my stuff!

Fantastic experience: Great place! Everyone is fun and friendly. Alexis is also a huge Zelda fan so that A+ in my book! Happy New Year!

Fantastic experience: Great service - friendly staff

Fantastic experience: Shout out to Kenny for getting me in and out! Great customer service!

Fantastic experience: Christina and jose made the trade in super easy and fast! Great experience

Fantastic experience: They were super kind as always and helpful. I appreciate you!

Fantastic experience: Amazing service, knowledgeable and pleasant. I know nothing about gaming systems and she’s a gamer expert!!

Fantastic experience: The staff is very friendly, store is clean. Always come here for my games!

Fantastic experience: Thank you Alexis for speedy service and a fair price. Also, very kind service.

Fantastic experience: Nice people, helpful and fair prices.

Fantastic experience: The biggest and nicest Disc Replay I've ever been too. Jose was a great employee to talk to, he helped me get 100% satisfaction with my visit.

Fantastic experience: Good service. They give me better selling offers than Gamestop.

Fantastic experience: Good prices, wish they had more PSP stuff but they had a few items for it. Bought one game for it(most are sports) and a few posters and a funko pop. Everyone was really nice and the prices are good. I would go back.

Fantastic experience: So great and so helpful! Alexis was wonderful to work with, very understanding and knowledgeable. Helped me get a great gift and I’m so grateful for everything! Thanks a million!

Positive experience: Take me to White amount of stock and most of the women there is the day I was there were pretty sharp there was one guy and he just really didn't know what was going on and wasn't that bright

Fantastic experience: They were very helpful, fast and gave fair prices

Fantastic experience: Lovely staff! Just moved near from Lafayette, and I had to check out the disc replay. I was in search of Silent Hill 2 and luckily enough, they had it. Well organized, lit, and stocked. I also bought a copy of Final fantasy x-x2 full priced only to find out it was missing x2. I returned the game even after having lost the recipt and they accepted my return after reviewing their records verified my initial purchase. Got in store credit (in this case i didnt mind.)

Fantastic experience: Bridgette is always a pleasure to work with. Jose and Christina have also been exceptional in helping me for years now. Consistently go above and beyond to ensure a great store experience and it’s what’s kept me coming back to this location instead of any other similar shops.

Fantastic experience: Christina was awesome! Came in to sell some games and it only took several minutes. She was kind and helpful.

Fantastic experience: Andrew provided excellent customer service, he found a game I was looking for, and answered my questions nicely. I traded Assassin's Creed Shadows PS5 for in store credit and found 4 great playstation games purchased today. This Disc Replay Castleton is awesome and friendly customer service. Huge selection. Thank you. - Jason

Fantastic experience: Went there today to trade in my playstation in for a OLED switch and the staff were extraordinarily helpful. Recommended me extra equipment and sent me on my merry way. The switch works perfectly and all the controllers as well. High quality stuff. This store is fantastic you should check it out.

Fantastic experience: It was an amazing experience! Their selection was nostalgic, competitive, and plentiful! Their staff was awesome and they even sell loose Pokemon cards! 5/5

Fantastic experience: Great store had some vintage games. I wanted some things. A few the lady wanted to play for the nes I needed some things. I always clean polite staff. Fun to stop in at whenever we're in the area

Fantastic experience: Alexis is literally the best. I love and look forward to talking movies/games/music with her everytime I come in.

Fantastic experience: I found the store strictly by happenstance while traveling for work. There is a ton of physical media ranging from 16 bit all the way through to current generation consoles. In addition to the games themselves, they have a bunch of game systems including a sega 32x still in the box. They have a plethora of dvd and bluray movies and tv series. If you have heard of Pink Gorilla in Seattle, this store has even more content than they have. The staff is friendly and told me about a mall with a working arcade room that also sells games at the counter, similar to Arcade Legacy in Sharonville Ohio. I am so glad that I stumbled upon this place. Edited for grammar on 10/10. My review was made on a phone whose predictive text is always wrong.

Fantastic experience: First time in the store and it was awesome! Definitely will be coming back!

Fantastic experience: This location has been my husband and I’s go to for some time now! Staff here is always nice and welcoming, and their selection is always changing (which is a great thing). We came in on Saturday and Christina S. immediately checked in on us and helped us look at some of the items in a case. She offered to hold our items at the front and helped check us out very quickly. She also helped us make sure we were well informed of our products warranty and was just exceptional.

Fantastic experience: Staff is friendly. Pleanty of gaming hardware, a whole wall of DVDs and a table of Pokemon cards. Happy hunting!

Fantastic experience: Great, friendly service never had a no problem. When I went in there they always answer my questions. They even helped my son find the game he was looking for totally great service.

Fantastic experience: This place is fantastic if you’re looking for games, consoles, and DVDs - older and newer. Bridgette was really helpful, and fun to chat with. Always have a good experience here, and usually find something worth finding.

Fantastic experience: Christina helped me and my girlfriend get some accessories for her ps2, was patient and knowledgeable and got us exactly what we needed

Fantastic experience: This place has pretty much everything and reasonably priced. Definitely recommend spending your money here!

Fantastic experience: I love this place so much and every time I come Alexis is working. She always has a good attitude and helped me find the complete set of my favorite show New Girl. She's personable, smiley and has really cool pink hair. 10/10 recommend this place

Fantastic experience: The people are always nice and they got good stuff, what’s not to love?

Fantastic experience: Hi this is PREME Alexis / Christina HELPED ME AND WERE VERY KNOWLEDGABLE about all electronics in the store . Please visit Disc Replay its a great environment , And these Ladies will get you in and out the store no long wait at all .

Fantastic experience: Great selection of movies, staff is always friendly and happy to answer questions. I always leave with a whole bag of stuff to add to my movie collection. Lots of cool posters and plushies too!

Negative experience: Gave super low prices for xbox 360 and ps4 games along with a ps4 slim 1tb they gave a total of 63 dollars gamestop offered 68 for just the ps4 and another 90 for all the games

Positive experience: Big store. Nice employees. Everything is in great condition!

Positive experience: Pretty good. Just an hour and a half wait after being told an hour

Fantastic experience: Christina was attentive, and politely called me back quickly with turning in my items for store credit. She also helped me to evaluate the price of a potential trade-ini. Top marks all around!

Fantastic experience: I love selling old junk that I don’t need and getting new stuff that I haven’t got in a while!

Fantastic experience: Traded in some items gave me a good offer for trade credit from christiana great customer service very friendly and giving a retro atmosphere will come again

Fantastic experience: Alexis was super friendly and helpful! She made everything so simple and gave excellent customer service!

Fantastic experience: Very nice and easy to talk to. He explained everything and helped make the process quick and pleasant. I will recommend Disc Replay to anyone looking to buy or sell. Great experience.

Fantastic experience: Very great place. Very friendly. Great service. Wonderful deals. It’s worth the trip. Ask for Christina, or Mars

Fantastic experience: Jose was very polite! And got my stuff check out fast! Team Jose!

Fantastic experience: I usually go to the one in Fort Wayne, but I always had good luck with the Castleton Disc replay. They always have hidden gems and games that you’re probably probably looking for for your collection.

Fantastic experience: Traded in a few extra GameCube games I had laying around. Quick easy and simple process. Christina is great.

Fantastic experience: Great selection of B Ray. Chris was very helpful. Thank U

Fantastic experience: Me and my friend came here and we found good movies and Kenny helped us and they were very nice and officiant

Fantastic experience: Alexis was great help, they helped me find exactly what I was looking for with a smile on their face! Great employee!

Fantastic experience: Tuff employee please give them 47$ instead of 5. Maybe even 48.

Fantastic experience: It was quick easy and they gave me a very fair price. I would go there again. They were very professional

Fantastic experience: Allyson was helpful in my decision making process today! Many thanks

Fantastic experience: Great selection of games for older consoles. Good prices for the sections I looked at as well.